Stan Startzell was a three-time soccer All-American (1969, 1970, 1971) playing on teams which participated in the NCAA Tournament for three consecutive years. He was also an All-Ivy place-kicker for the 1971 football team. At the time, he was the only athlete to be named All-Ivy in two sports in the same season.
He scored 18 goals in his varsity career, and assisted on 16 goals by teammates. Startzell was the recipient of the David L. Gould Trophy as the team’s most valuable player as a senior.